I doubt anyone is unaware of what happened at Virginia Tech yesterday. A young man, a student, took firearms and killed over 32 other students and professors. At the end, he walked into one of the schools buildings, chained the doors shut and began killing people. Not one of his victims, or potential victims, was armed, of course, the school being a gun-free zone. His victims had no chance.
How would things gave gone differently if the school permitted students with concealed carry permits to carry on campus? We'll never know. How would things have been differently if even one of the students or professors in the building was armed? How could it have gone differently. At least there would have been a chance to reduce the loss of life.
Neal Boortz asked this question on his radio show, today: If you could, would you have armed at least one of the students or professors? Let's suppose, he asks, you could sneak a gun through an A/C grate to a student in the building. Would you? Now ask yourself why you would not want to permit qualified law abiding people to possess firearms on that campus.
Concealed carry holders statistically a) are not involved in accidental shootings (any mis-use of their firearms) and b) are not involved in illegal use of their firearms. As these people do not present a threat at other times, why would you not want them to be on-hand and capable of acting under these rare but tragic circumstances?
By ensuring that the college is a gun free zone, sadly, a ready pool of defenseless victims stands by at all times for events just like this one.
Showing posts with label Second Amendment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Second Amendment. Show all posts
Tuesday, April 17, 2007
Friday, March 9, 2007
March 10 - 2nd Amendment Victory
A case has been in review for a while in D.C. This case is important for two reasons. One is that it is reviewing the rights of an individual to keep and bear arms. The other is that this review is being held in a Federal Court of Appeals. Why this is important is because the decision, depending on which way it goes, will set the course for gun ownership rights for a long time to come. This is one of the first serious challenges to the second amendment to come along in several years. It is made serious by virtue of the fact that the challenge comes in a federal jurisdiction, bypassing all the state level challenges that don't mean so much.
The four year old case is challenging D.C.'s law that prohibits personal ownership and possession of pistols in ones own home. Most federal courts hold the opinion that the second amendment pertains to the right of states to have an armed militia, not that the individual has a right to own a firearm. The Supreme Court has not ruled on this matter in since the 1930's. If the decision were to come down in favor of the law, it would establish an opinion by a federal court that would be unlikely to survive further challenge and severely weaken gun ownership rights in this country.
Today, it was announced that the appeals court had the good sense to overturn D.C.'s law. Washington city leadership has vowed to appeal which all but assures that this matter will come before the supreme court. Given the present makeup of the SCOTUS, there is an excellent chance that the country will return to a condition where the second amendment has a more similar meaning to that intended by the country's founders.
D.C.'s leaders all say that their intent is to reduce gun violence. It is odd that their position is at odds with the verified findings of the last ten years that improving access to firearms tends to curb violent crime while increasing property crime. It seems that when you make owning a firearm a crime, the law abiding turn in their guns but those who don't abide by the law keep theirs. All over the country, where states have enacted concealed carry laws there has been a corresponding and correlated reduction in violent crime.
Maybe with this ruling, D.C.'s leaders will get the reduced violence they want. I wonder which they want more?
The four year old case is challenging D.C.'s law that prohibits personal ownership and possession of pistols in ones own home. Most federal courts hold the opinion that the second amendment pertains to the right of states to have an armed militia, not that the individual has a right to own a firearm. The Supreme Court has not ruled on this matter in since the 1930's. If the decision were to come down in favor of the law, it would establish an opinion by a federal court that would be unlikely to survive further challenge and severely weaken gun ownership rights in this country.
Today, it was announced that the appeals court had the good sense to overturn D.C.'s law. Washington city leadership has vowed to appeal which all but assures that this matter will come before the supreme court. Given the present makeup of the SCOTUS, there is an excellent chance that the country will return to a condition where the second amendment has a more similar meaning to that intended by the country's founders.
D.C.'s leaders all say that their intent is to reduce gun violence. It is odd that their position is at odds with the verified findings of the last ten years that improving access to firearms tends to curb violent crime while increasing property crime. It seems that when you make owning a firearm a crime, the law abiding turn in their guns but those who don't abide by the law keep theirs. All over the country, where states have enacted concealed carry laws there has been a corresponding and correlated reduction in violent crime.
Maybe with this ruling, D.C.'s leaders will get the reduced violence they want. I wonder which they want more?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)